“…And with that die roll, the fiendish Orc King is finally flushed out of hiding. Boobarella, your voluptuous half-elf/half-dragon girlfriend, says a titillating surprise awaits you back at camp.”
“Dude, that’s total bullshit! I thought Boobarella was my girlfriend!”
“But I traded you all my Spawn figures for Boobarella,” screams the second pimply teenager in disbelief. “No take backs!”
“There’s more than enough Boobarella to go around,” snorts Phil, the third.
“Phil, we’re talking about my cherished Spawn collection here, including the ultra-rare, three-eyed, promo variation of…”
“Look, I’m gonna put on some music while you guys argue.”
Three seconds into the first track of Mountains, Robert (the chubby one) spits his Mountain Dew all over the Dungeon Master’s Guide. “Dude, this is, like, girl music!”
“Jesus, Phil, just give it a chance! Listen to the arrangements on this album: medieval-period instruments, intelligently-applied synthesizers, and minimalistic, bouncy guitar lines that swirl in and out of the mix in the most elegant way. This is beautiful indie rock.”
“Or a great soundtrack for our next AD&D campaign,” quips Phil.
“No, more like a Geddy Lee / Lou Barlow duet,” says Jordan.
“I was thinking more along the lines of a King Crimson-produced Polvo record or Joni Mitchell playing at a comic book convention,” says Robert.
“Don’t ask me how I know this,” says Jordan. “But Mountains is a unique concept album that no one expected from Mary Timony. The fantasy-novel lyrics aren’t another trite batch of indie irony, but a sincere effort by a girl every guy in the comic book shop would love to date. Sincerity like this is sorely lacking in indie music.”
“But does sincere mean good,” asks Robert, rhetorically. “Faux medieval instrumentals like ‘Whisper From A Tree’ aren’t interesting or surprising after one listen. What’s worse, half the album is made up of songs like that.”
“True, dude, but string-bending rockers like ‘An-Deluzion’ and ‘Painted Horses’ are pleasantly out of left-field. Multi-layered synthesizers wail along with guitars in every song, but with Timony’s ear for harmony, they don’t sound at all cheesy. The major problem is the sheer sameness of everything; you really can’t tell when one song ends and another begins. Mountains would be better as an EP; in its full-length incarnation, it drags on forever,” says Jordan.
“Final verdict,” says Robert. It’s a dark and pretty guilty pleasure that you’ll listen to a few times when no one else is home. You don’t want to like it, but it grabs you by the gerbils in spite of itself.”
“A worthwhile purchase if found in a used CD bin,” says Jordan.
“One last thing,” says Robert, turning to Dungeon Master Phil.
“Yeah?”
“What was my nearly-complete set of Betty Page trading cards doing between your mattresses?”
“Now, dude, I can explain…”